Flipsy Cards

Your Premier Card Marketplace

Sign in for the best experience

Members get a smarter, more personalized marketplace — here's what you unlock:

  • Personalized Card Suggestions

    We learn what you collect and surface cards you'll actually want.

  • Auction & Deal Notifications

    Never miss a live auction or a rare find — get alerts your way.

  • Sell Your Cards

    Become a seller, list your collection, and reach thousands of buyers.

Get the Flipsy App

Faster browsing, instant access

Add to your home screen

Open this site on your phone to install the app for quick access

Back to Shop
1990 Post First Collector Series Mark McGwire #12
✓

1990 Post First Collector Series Mark McGwire #12

Baseball
1990
Excellent 7

Player: Mark McGwire

Brand: Post

Description

Own a piece of baseball history with this 1990 Post First Collector Series Mark McGwire #12. During the late 1980s and early 1990s, few players captured the imagination of fans like "Big Mac." As a cornerstone of the legendary Oakland Athletics "Bash Brothers," McGwire was in the midst of a historic run that would eventually cement his legacy as one of the most feared power hitters in the game’s history. This card captures the essence of that era, featuring the slugger in his iconic A’s green and gold during the height of his physical prime. This card is part of Post’s inaugural "First Collector Series," a nostalgic promotion that brought the thrill of the hobby back to the breakfast table. Because these cards were originally printed on the back of cereal boxes and intended to be hand-cut by consumers, finding examples with clean borders and well-preserved surfaces is a unique challenge for modern hobbyists. This #12 card features a crisp image and vibrant colors, serving as a standout example of 1990s "food-issue" collectibles, which have seen a significant resurgence in popularity among vintage enthusiasts. Whether you are a devoted Oakland Athletics fan, a Mark McGwire completist, or a collector of unique 90s oddball sets, this Post First Collector Series card is an essential addition to any portfolio. It represents a golden age of baseball production and a time when McGwire’s towering home runs were the talk of the sports world. Don't miss the opportunity to secure this well-preserved piece of nostalgia and celebrate the career of one of the game's ultimate titans.

Authenticated

Insured Shipping

Verified Seller

FLIPSY Score

7.5/10

MID GRADE

Data Confidence: MEDIUM

Ref: PSA 8 avg $107.02 · Actual Auction Data

Scan ID: FS-A296-X

Tap to view breakdown

Price

Final Sale

$2

↑ PSA 9 upside: ~$10.63

Ref: Actual Auction Data (Last 90 Days)

Verified by Flipsy AI

Technical Grading Matrix

FLIPSY Score

7.8

Centering8/10
Corners7/10
Edges7.5/10
Surface8.5/10
PSA 10 Confidence88%
© Flipsy AI — Proprietary Grade Analysis
🔬

Forensic Edge Report

MEF Engine · Heatmap · Arbitrage · Authentication

No Book Prices. No Guesses. Just the Market.

Ref: Actual Auction Data (Last 90 Days) · PSA · eBay · Goldin · Cardladder · PWCC

⚡ High Arbitrage

Market Range · Based on FLIPSY 7.8 Score

PSA 7

NM

—

PSA 8 ← Your Grade

NM-MT

Anchor

$16

+700% vs raw

Actual Auction Data

PSA 9

Mint

$50

+2400% vs raw

View full grade spectrum (PSA 1–10)

PSA 3

—

PSA 4

—

PSA 5

—

PSA 6

—

PSA 7

—

PSA 8

$16

+700%

PSA 9

$50

+2400%

PSA 10

$107

+5250%

Realized Upside to PSA 9

PSA 9 Value

$50

Fees + Shipping

-$44

Net Profit

+$4

Grading fee ~$19 · Shipping ~$25 · Actual auction comps

The 1990 Post Cereal Mark McGwire #12 is a mass-produced food-issue card. Market liquidity is low for high-grade copies, and the card does not command significant premiums due to high supply and lack of rookie status. Profit margins are thin after accounting for grading and shipping costs.

Ref: Actual Auction Data (Last 90 Days) · Not a guarantee of grade or value.